Judge rules Puddles will be returned to his original owners.
The family in Alice, Texas will get its dog back as the judge ruled that the former mayor had wrongly kidnapped him.
The judge said, “I think a lot of this is just plain ridiculous.”
He stated that former mayor Grace Saenz-Lopez and her neighbors, the original owners, Rudy Gutierrez and Shelly Cavasos, should have resolved the dispute out of court.
He ruled that Saenz-Lopez should not have agreed to take care of Puddles while his family went on vacation last July and then told them that Puddles was dead while she hid the dog with her sister. Although she presented evidence that Puddles was gravely ill when the family left him, the judge ruled that evidence of the dog’s medical condition was irrelevant.
He denied the Gutierrez-Cavasos claim for court costs—nearly $10,000.
Saenz-Lopez and her sister both face criminal charges.
While it is wrong to kidnap a dog, Saenz-Lopez seems to be a loving if misguided person with compassionate motives. The words from A Chorus Line run through my head:










