Ok, maybe I am overstating just a little bit, but Jimmy sent me a link to "The Horror of Disney’s Old Yeller." It is quite a brilliant piece of writing, meaning, of course, that I completely agree with it.
Most of you know that I have never quite gotten over the movie, Old Yeller. In case you haven’t been traumatized by it, the dog Old Yeller gets hydrophobia by biting a wolf to save his family. When he gets sick, the little boy who loves him has to shoot him. Yeah, like that.
Although it may be an excellent film, it is not one for children. The writer takes us scene by scene through the movie to support his contention that the movie is:
…one of the most disturbing "children’s movies" in cinema history. While ostensibly a coming-of-age story … everything in this film is structured around a single horrifying sequence — highly traumatic to the typical child viewer — in which a good dog turned bad is killed by the boy who loved him. Such traumatic moments are not rare in the works of producer Walt Disney.
Now that he mentions it I also found some of the scenes in Snow White and Bambi to be far too intense for a child my age when I saw them. I can remember that they gave me nightmares for…well, the last one was the night before last.
He concludes:
But Old Yeller isn’t just about child abuse; it is child abuse, as any number of viewers who saw it in their youth can attest. Disney was unquestionably one of the most gifted storytellers in the medium, but far too often his storytelling gifts were used to make child viewers experience vicariously the same horrors and losses that had traumatized him. I wouldn’t take a sensitive child to Old Yeller any more than I would deny that child the experience of Fantasia.
Ah, Fantasia. One of the great experiences at the movies.
Thanks, Jimmy